Spooky Treasures: Halloween Collectibles at Jeffrey S. Evans’ Summer Americana Sale

Halloween may still be weeks away, but collectors of vintage holiday memorabilia will have plenty to get excited about this month. On August 27, 2025, Jeffrey S. Evans & Associates presents Summer Americana: Day 1, a sale brimming with folk art, advertising, toys, and nostalgic treasures. Among the highlights are a handful of rare and highly collectible Halloween-themed lots, perfect for enthusiasts who cherish the eerie charm of early 20th-century holiday décor.
Here are five standout pieces crossing the block:

German Papier-Mâché Jack-o’-Lantern
A classic expression of Halloween tradition, this German papier-mâché lantern embodies the handmade craftsmanship that makes early jack-o’-lanterns so desirable. Collectors value these for their delicate construction and ability to evoke the mischievous spirit of vintage Halloween nights.

Lot #30
Circa 1925
Papier-mache or pressed cardboard
Estimate: $50 - $80

Cat on Fence Lanterns (Lot of Two)
Black cats have long been symbols of mystery and superstition, and this pair of American papier-mâché lanterns captures that lore perfectly. Designed to glow with candles inside, they once flickered in windows and on porches during Halloween festivities.

Lot #33
Circa 1950
Papier-mache
Estimate: $100 - $200

Papier-Mâché Figures (Lot of Two)
Early pulp figures like these were both decorations and toys, beloved for their whimsical yet spooky designs. Their survival today, given how fragile they are, makes them particularly appealing to dedicated collectors.

Lot #36
Circa 1945
Papier-mache
Estimate: $150 - $250

J. Chein Tin Lithographed Tambourine
No Halloween celebration in the early 20th century was complete without noisemakers. This tin-lithographed tambourine by J. Chein features a black cat motif, combining festive fun with graphic artistry. Such pieces are coveted for their vibrant lithography and nostalgic appeal.

Lot #37
Circa 1925
Pressed and lithographed tin
Estimate: $50 - $100

Vintage German Steiff Halloween Black Cat
From the iconic German toy company Steiff comes this plush black cat, an unexpected but delightful Halloween collectible. Steiff animals are prized by both toy and holiday collectors, making this an especially crossover piece with broad appeal.

Lot #40
Second half 20th century
Steiff stuffed black cats
Estimate: $80 - $120

Whether you’re a seasoned holiday enthusiast or just beginning your journey into the world of vintage Halloween décor, these lots showcase the charm, artistry, and history that make such pieces endlessly collectible.

The Jeffrey S. Evans Summer Americana Sale: Part 1 takes place August 27, 2025. Explore the full catalog and place your bids on Bidsquare.com.